Friday, June 10, 2011

Is the Presidency merely a Rubber Stamp?

Former Senior Minister S Jayakumar says that he is surprised and disappointed by the statements made by some of the presidential candidate hopefuls.
Well, truth be told, I am just as disappointed with the statements made by Professor Jayakumar which has only served to confirm what many of us have long believed to be true – that the President is only there to rubber stamp government’s decisions, even if such decisions may not be to the liking of the people.
In stating that the President only has some discretionary custodial powers, which is limited to blocking government decisions when it impacts on the protection of the reserves or appointments to key public offices or on matters related to ISA detentions, CPIB investigations and Maintenance of Religious Harmony Act restraining order, and that in all other areas, the President under the Constitution must act on the advice of the Cabinet, Prof Jayakumar has managed to show to Singaporeans that for all intents and purposes, the President is but a paper tiger.
Prof Jayakumar’s statements suggest that the government has hard-coded its relationship logic with the President in such a way as to ensure a harmonious relationship with a PAP-supportive President and in the case of a not so PAP-supportive President, ensure a benign presidency that can do little to effectively act as the people’s guardian.
No surprise that such a clarification on the legal position of the President has come from Prof Jayakumar since he was one of the key architects in the crafting of the Elected President laws when he was Law Minister in the 1980s.
In one fell swoop, Prof Jayakumar, who has indicated that he will not be contesting the presidency, has for dismissed the goals outlined by the two frontrunners in the forthcoming presidential election due by 31 August, suggesting that their lofty ambitions were simply ambitions.
I would like to say to Prof Jayakumar that we, the citizens, are fully aware that the office of the President is one without executive powers, that the President has no power to initiate decisions or policy, but we are also of the belief that given the stringent qualifying criteria stipulated for one to be considered eligible for the office of the President, the person elected by the people as President would have the substance and wherewithal to engage, advise and even disagree with the government privately in matters relating to Singapore’s assets and appointment of top leaders and require them to review their decision.
I would hate it if the President is there to merely read the documents tabled to him and sign off on them without having formed an opinion and raised questions on decisions taken by the government. Why would we need an Elected President, one who is chosen by and accountable to the people who voted for him, if he is there to simply and unquestionably endorse all government decisions?
Looking at the goals articulated by some of the presidential hopefuls, in all honesty, I would have to say that they are well-within the scope of the Articles 21 and 22 (in particular Article 22F President’s access to information) in the Constitution. No where have they suggested the expansion of their role to include executive powers or to see themselves as a centre of power distinct from the government. If anything, their goal is to be able to work more effectively with the government of the day, without feeling as though they had to do so with one hand tied behind their back.
While the form of the Articles in the Constitution does seem to suggest limits on the power of the President, it is in implementation of those Articles that we should hope for there to be a generous and judicious exercise of discretion and judgement to ensure responsibility and accountability in government and governance.
Given the current climate of change following the watershed May 2011 General Election and the open season on sacred cows, should we not adopt a somewhat more enlightened approach to the relevant articles in the Constitution, that is, while we should respect the spirit of the intent of said articles, we should not be overly dogmatic in circumscribing the powers of the President to the point that he is reduced to being nothing more than a rubber stamp.
Ultimately, I believe that Singaporeans are clear about their expectations of the role of the President. We know that the President has limited powers, but I also believe that we would like the President to be able to counsel the government through a process of engagement with the Prime Minister and his Cabinet and active deliberations of government decisions.
This engagement and deliberation would be predicated on the President having a good feel of the pulse of the ground, which should be the case since the President is after all elected by the people for the people.
And only if he can truly do that, can we honestly say that we have our next people’s president.

Afternote: As of Friday evening, Minister for Law K Shanmugam had issued a statement to reiterate the points that have been made by former Senior Minister S Jayakumar and President S R Nathan, which is that the President only has custodial powers and not executive powers. Hmm, tell me something we don't already know.... .

Time for a Malay President?

As Singapore gears up to choose its 7th president (assuming that President Nathan decides to sit out the race), I cannot help but look at the list of presidential hopefuls and notice the telling absence of a potential candidate from the Malay/Muslim community.
The one and only time a Malay/Muslim held the office was upon the independence of Singapore in 1965, when Yusof Ishak was appointed President. He held the office until his passing in November 1970 and since then, the office of the President has been filled, in order of turn, by a Eurasian, an Indian, a Chinese, a Chinese and an Indian.
In the spirit of Singapore’s multiracialism, it would seem only logical that a Malay/Muslim Singaporean should be given the opportunity to fill this high office to be our head of state this time round. It seems to be the right thing to do, doesn’t it?
Should there be no candidate from the Malay/Muslim community on nomination day, by the time the next presidential election comes about in 2017, 52 years would have passed since a Malay/Muslim served as Singapore’s head of state.
But the current reality is that the Presidency is no longer an appointed position. Since 1991, the office of the President had evolved by way of a Constitutional amendment to become an elected office, where the president is chosen through a popular vote after having been first certified eligible to contest the post based on a set of rigorous criteria.
And since the presidency is now a contested post, the perceived arrangement of ethnic rotation for the post no longer applies. The onus thus rests with the community to ensure that there are suitably qualified candidates from the community.
We are after all a nation that holds to the principle of meritocracy and aspirants to this august office must rightly so submit themselves to be evaluated on the basis of merit against the requirements enshrined in Article 19(2) of the Constitution.
Going through the list of requirements, I could imagine a number of Malay/Muslim individuals from the public and private sector who could be suitable for nomination as a presidential hopeful but when I get to Article 19(2)(g), I suddenly see my list quickly reducing in number until I am left with a very short list. The “talent” pool in the Malay/Muslim community, as a consequence of circumstance, is rather limited, wouldn’t you agree?
This very short list includes former minister and Speaker of Parliament Mr Abdullah Tarmugi, former ministers Dr Ahmad Mattar and Mr Othman Wok and former Members of Parliament Dr Ahmad Magad (who is also a group managing director in a multinational company) and Mr Zainul Abidin Rasheed (who was a Senior Minister of State for Foreign Affairs and had been Chief Executive Officer of Mendaki and President of the Islamic Religious Council prior to entering politics).
While their credentials do seem to qualify them for nomination, age and possibly health for at least two of them (Mr Othman is 87 and Dr Ahmad Mattar is 72), and affiliation to the People’s Action Party (PAP) for all of them would present challenges to their candidacy. After all, didn’t the PAP come out quickly to state that Singaporeans may prefer a President who was not so closely linked to the party when Dr Tan Cheng Bock announced himself as a candidate for the presidential election?
Talk about shooting oneself in the foot! Because the very reasoning used in the attempt to derail Dr Tan’s candidacy applies just as well to all the potential Malay/Muslim candidates I have named and any other person who has been a member of the PAP.
Who else can the Malay/Muslim community come up with as a presidential hopeful? A name that comes to mind and one that comes across as being apolitical is Mr Ridzwan Dzafir, the former Director-General of the Trade Development Board. He has been credited as being one of Singapore’s most outstanding civil servants. However, Mr Ridzwan, who would be 84 this year, would probably not want to step into the fray, possibly on account of his health and age.
This leads me back to where I started, with no real candidate to suggest for the Malay/Muslim community’s “turn” at the presidency. I would gladly love to be proven wrong and would love for that person to put himself forward for the consideration of the people of Singapore in this presidential election.
Failing which, the Malay/Muslim community will have another six years to hope that someone of suitable quality and caliber will step forward as a presidential hopeful. Alternatively, the community can take the initiative to identify, actively cultivate and prepare a suitable person to contest the next presidential election in 2017.
If you ask me, if the community hopes to see one of its own ascend to the highest office in the land, it should not just sit back and leave it to chance.

Afternote: A possible Malay/Muslim presidential hopeful had turned up at the Elections Department on Friday, 10 June to collect the Certificate of Eligibility forms. But just how serious a candidate is Mohamed Raffi Bashir Ahmed given that he is under police investigation for allegedly driving a van spray-painted with expletives into the Islamic Religious Council of Singapore premises.

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Third Term for President Nathan? What Say You?


In a surprising twist, President S R Nathan may very well be on the slate for the upcoming Presidential Election. The man, after all, has not indicated that he will not be contesting the office, but has indicated that he is still deciding on whether to seek a third term of office.
Mr Nathan, who is already 87, has however conceded that his age will be factor in his deliberation.
So, should Mr Nathan seek a third term or should he hand over the reins to a slate of new candidates who may possibly bring with them fresh perspectives on the role and responsibilities of the Elected President?
Growing list of presidential hopefuls
To date, three men have declared their intention to contest the election: Former People’s Action Party (PAP) Member of Parliament (MP) Dr Tan Cheng Bock, 71; former NTUC Income chief Mr Tan Kin Lian, 63; and businessman Mr Ooi Boon Ewe, 70. (Mr Ooi is a doubtful starter given that he may not be able to meet some of the basic criteria).
Also up for consideration is former Foreign Minister Mr George Yeo, 57, although his inclusion in the list of potential candidates is more driven by the populist desires of his young fans and supporters. I have already discussed why Mr Yeo should not run for president – well, at least not in this presidential election – and I similarly think that Mr Nathan too should do the honorable thing and step aside.
Another name that has surfaced is former Deputy Prime Minister Dr Tony Tan, 71, who has not explicitly rule himself out of the race when asked if he would make a bid for the job. Dr Tony Tan is currently the executive director of the Government of Singapore Investment Corporation (GIC) and chairman of Singapore Press Holdings (SPH). These portfolios could very well work against him, given the negative public sentiment towards both the GIC and SPH. However, even if he relinquishes both portfolios, the recency of his ties with these organizations, as will his affiliation with the PAP, may well be counted against him by voters.
But what about Mr Nathan? Besides already being an octogenarian, Mr Nathan is seen as being too close to the establishment, and by this, I mean the PAP establishment. Lest we forget, his two terms of office had been ‘won’ uncontested and he had come unto the scene in 1999 to be the second Elected President as a PAP endorsed candidate. His nomination was strongly supported by none other than Mr Lee Kuan Yew himself.
Going by current ground sentiments in post-2011 General Elections Singapore, I would rate Mr Nathan’s chances of being returned to office as being very, very slim. Rather than suffer the ignominy of an election defeat, it may be better for Mr Nathan to retire with dignity and look forward to the publication of his memoirs in September, which among others will include the highlights and challenges of his tenure. I am sure that whoever is elected our next President can take a leaf from his memoirs to ensure an effective presidency.
Mr Nathan’s relationship with the PAP government has also been described as ‘amicable’, although some critics take a more cynical view and see it as a ‘hand in glove’ relationship, and he would be hard pressed to change this perception if he wishes to submit himself to the judgement of the people in this upcoming election.
President with a vision
The bar, too, has been set high for all presidential hopefuls given the platforms that have been put forth by the two frontrunners. Dr Tan has adopted a moral high ground position of being the people’s champion and a unifying voice to heal this fractured nation while Mr Tan has taken the everyday man approach of offering concrete plans of action in calling for an annual report on the Singapore reserves (including the Central Provident Fund) and promising to lead the way in reforming political salaries.
And looking even more closely at the two leading presidential hopefuls, it would appear that Mr Tan’s clearly thought through plan of action, should he be elected president, has put him ahead in the race, ahead even of Dr Tan, whose 26 year political career has endeared him to many Singaporeans from all walks of life.
And despite the dampener that Mr Nathan has seemingly thrown onto Mr Tan’s plans, it is not beyond the realm of reason to achieve those plans, especially if one approaches the job with “principles, independence, commonsense and the ability to ask the right questions and do the right things, without fear or favor” as succinctly put by Dr Tan.  
While Mr Nathan see the presidency as an office that “operates on the Constitution – and what is possible and what is not possible is determined by that”, it would be remiss to accept such an assertion at face value without making an effort to flesh out how the relevant articles in the Constitution can be implemented in the greater interest of the people of Singapore and not just the government of the day.
Compared to the other hopefuls I have listed above, I would describe both Dr Tan and Mr Tan as political mavericks (and I use the term political in its non-partisan form), simply for their individual courage and conviction to speak up for what they believe in, without any thought of their own personal gain.
They clearly realize that if elected, they will come to office during a period of enormous change and their individually articulated visions for their presidency clearly suggest that they see a need for the evolution of the role of the president.
Despite having been a PAP member until recently, Dr Tan has always had a reputation for speaking his mind and sometimes breaking rank with the party, which had resulted in him being censured by the party. This would suggest that in Dr Tan, it would be possible to see a President who will ensure that the government does not just operate with a blank cheque.
And in taking up the cause of trying to unify the people of Singapore, Dr Tan could help repair the 60-40 divide that has fractured our society. Imagine the ‘kingmaker’ role that such a president could play if he were to succeed in bringing the people together, especially if he is seen to be above party politics. And given the possibility of Singapore moving towards a two party dominance system, it would require us to have a head of state that can look beyond party colors and call upon the leaders of parties on opposite sides of the political divide to find the middle ground.
Like Dr Tan, Mr Tan’s plans also ensure that the government operates with full accountability and transparency, with the president in full knowledge of the status of the reserves. This will ensure that the president is able to discharge his custodial duties without having to try to second guess the government. Should Mr Tan be able to realize this, it would be an ultimate homage to the work that had been started by the late President Ong Teng Cheong, Singapore’s first Elected President.  
Mr Tan’s pledge to take only $300,000 of the President’s $4 million annual salary and donating the rest to a charity for causes he believes in, will probably win him many fans and supporters, which ultimately translate into votes. It is also by far the most concrete indication of the degree of prudence that his presidency will exercise. The presidency is, after all, a calling to serve the nation and its people, and not a job.
A President for your future
Even before the Writ of Election has been issued, it is clear that the campaigning to win the hearts and minds of the people have begun, at least by the two frontrunners, all thanks to the facility and efficacy of the Internet and the many social media channels.
Where once the Singapore polity was thought to be apathetic about anything to do with politics and governance, there is now a much heightened and greater sense of awareness of the need to register one’s view and participate in the decision making process.
Even though the presidential election is not a political battle, it is a matter of equal importance for through our vote we put in place a man who will be charged with the duty to protect our interests and to ensure that the government of the day acts in our interest.
It is ultimately our future that we decide on when we go to the ballot box, and my wish is that we choose a President who will ensure that we have a future to look forward to.

Monday, June 6, 2011

Elected President Race Gets Interesting

It’s barely a month since he lost his seat as an elected Member of Parliament and his position as a Minister in Singapore’s government, but George Yeo still seems to have an appetite for electoral battle.
He has emerged as a potential candidate for the upcoming Elected President election, going by a posting in his Facebook page and the appearance of a delegation at the Elections Department to collect a certificate of eligibility form for Mr Yeo.
The presidential race may not be as heated as the recent general election, given that candidates do not contest on a party platform, but voters will still be judging each candidate on their merit, character, credibility, and ability before casting their vote for the person whom they truly believe can be the people’s guardian.
To date, four names have been thrown into the fray, with former MP Dr Tan Cheng Bock and businessman Mr Ooi Boon Ewe having declared their intention to contest the election and former NTUC Income chief Mr Tan Kin Lian and Mr George Yeo indicating their interest (by way of the collection of the certificate of eligibility form via proxies).
As contenders for the presidential office have until three days after the issuance of the writ of election to submit their forms, we will probably have to wait with bated breath to find out if this will be a two-horse race or more. Unless anyone else steps forward, I see this as a possible three-horse race comprising Dr Tan, Mr Tan and Mr Yeo as Mr Ooi would probably not meet the eligibility requirements.
George Yeo for President?
Mr Yeo’s possible participation in the elections (he has given himself two weeks to come to a final decision) comes as a surprise because he had all but ruled himself out when he announced his retirement from politics following his defeat in the 2011 general election. Apparently driven by pleas from his fans to run for president, Mr Yeo is now “thinking hard about and praying for wisdom”.
If I were him, I would, with the utmost humility and respect to his supporters, not take part in the presidential election for a variety of reasons.
Firstly, the May 2011 general election had seen a sea change in the voter behavior against the People’s Action Party (PAP), giving it the lowest margin of victory since it came to power. Anti-PAP sentiment is still running high. There are still many unresolved issues and the recent floods have only served to further sour the already tenuous relationship between the PAP-led government and the polity.
Given the continuity of such sentiments and also the assessment of a standing PAP MP and a former PAP minister that candidates who are closely linked to the party will not be preferred by voters, the most logical decision for Mr Yeo is to not contest the highest office in the land.
It would also be two-faced and absolutely insincere of the PAP to suddenly change the stance it took in response to Dr Tan Cheng Bock’s declared candidacy, should George Yeo decide to run the race. It would also suggest that the PAP believe that they would have a more PAP-friendly president in Mr Yeo as compared to Dr Tan.
Mr Yeo also has the burden of having been part of the inner circle of power in PAP, while Dr Tan was clearly a maverick backbencher within the party even though he had been part of the Central Executive Committee. While Mr Yeo had toed the party line and espoused the mantra of the government, Dr Tan had often-times stood by his principles and spoken up against the party and government.
Secondly, it would be naïve of Mr Yeo’s supporters to believe that if elected as President, Mr Yeo could be the type of leader the younger generation could rally around. The promise of engaging the younger generation was made in the context of Mr Yeo being returned to Parliament by way of the general election. Had he been returned to office, Mr Yeo would probably have introduced initiatives that would have enabled the government to tap into and understand the younger polity as part of a bigger effort to “re-invent” and reform the party to make it relevant to the post-65 generation so as to secure their votes.
On the other hand, as an elected president, Mr Yeo would not have any form to executive powers to effect change. As President, he would only have custodial powers over the reserves and appointment to key public offices. While he would be able to engage the younger generation and be close to the people on the ground, his role would be more of a kind, fatherly figure who lends a listening ear. In the best case scenario, he may be able to convey the feelings and desires of the people to the government but that would be the limit of his impact on policy-making, and I do not see this changing unless the government decides to broaden the scope of powers accorded to the President.
Thirdly, Mr Yeo himself had stated that his temperament was not suited for the job. As President, Mr Yeo’s free-spiritedness would be all but curtailed and if we truly value the deep thinker that he is, we should not wish upon him this august office. This office would relegate Mr Yeo to, at most, social roles and ceremonial duties. Given his standing both regionally and in the international arena, Mr Yeo would serve the nation and the polity better in a role that transcends national boundaries or as the head of a supra-national think tank.
Also, if Singaporeans truly hope to see the PAP make real steps in re-inventing, reforming and transforming itself and believe that George Yeo has a part to play in that, then his being outside of the circle of governance, as an outsider looking in after having been inside, will require that he continue to be part of the PAP and not be distanced from the party as an elected president (as he would have to resign from the PAP).
Time for candidates to start engaging voters
No one knows for sure when the writ of election will be issued by the Elections Department, all we know is that the election must be held by 31 August. It could be as soon as two weeks from now, going by Mr Yeo’s comment that he will make a decision within two weeks (and given his past ties to the establishment, he may be privy to when the election has been planned for).
As the weeks ahead play out, Singaporeans will have a growing desire to have a greater understanding of the potential contenders. They will want to know more about each candidate, what they stand for, what they hope to achieve and how they will make a difference (within the boundaries of the office they are contesting).
We already have a feel of Dr Tan’s agenda and his possible platform based on what he has shared in his webpage, while Mr Yeo’s possible candidacy seems to be a “rebound” effect arising from his election defeat. Both appear to be populist candidates and each has their fair share of followers. The other two candidates have thus far not shared much, save for a declaration of intent by one (Mr Ooi) and an indication of intent by the other (Mr Tan).
So, my call to all the potential candidates is to not spare any effort to reach out to Singaporeans. Make use of all available channels to touch Singaporeans so that as voters we know who you are and what you stand for. Engage us so that we know that you are keeping your ear to the ground and actually listen to our concerns. Ultimately, when we go to the ballot box, we want to be able to make an informed choice when choose our next president.
At the end of the day, we want a people’s president.
A president we can be proud of.

Addendum 1 (7 June 2011): Following the publication of this posting, Mr Tan Kin Lian has indicated in his blog on 7 June that he will be contesting the presidential election. The race is really heating up; and in both Dr Tan and Mr Tan, Singaporeans can be sure of having a president who will have the interest of the people at heart.


Addendum 2 (15 June 2011): Mr George Yeo has decided not to contest the office of the Elected President after having taken about two weeks to think about it and consider the views of family, friends and Singaporeans.

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

To Heal a Nation

Tomorrow marks the first day of June, and it is a day that many of us are looking forward to because it is the day that we find out who is ready to stand up to be Singapore’s unifying figure to heal the rift that has polarized our society.
Going by the chatter one hears both offline and online, and despite the calls of leaders on both sides of the political divide for Singaporeans to close ranks to work together for our common future, we are still very much divided by our loyalty to the familiar and desire for change.
Cynicism too, seems to be running rampant as citizen activism continues to flourish in the wake of the recent general elections. We are, after all, an awakened polity, powered by the greater diversity of information and views that is now available to us at our fingertips to form our own conclusions. No longer do we just allow ourselves to be dictated to by the mainstream media.
Left unchecked, this polarization of our society could very well tear us apart, and this is definitely not going to be good for you and me, for our families, for our children, and for Singapore as a nation.
This task of healing the nation must fall on the shoulders of our next President, a non-partisan head of state, who will be scrutinized and elected by the people. For the President to be able to succeed in this task, he/she must truly be the people’s choice and not just someone who has the endorsement of the government, in this case, the ruling People’s Action Party (PAP).
What we need is a People’s President in the truest sense of the word. Besides playing a key custodial role in guarding our reserves and ensuring transparency in appointments to key public offices, the next President must possess the qualities and skills that will enable him/her to unify Singaporeans from all walks of life and get them to move forward with a common purpose.
In this unifying role, the President must be seen to be the embodiment of the core values enshrined in our pledge, and that regardless of race, language or religion, he/she will ensure that Singapore is “a democratic society based in justice and equality, so as to achieve happiness, prosperity and progress for our nation”.
After the political awakening in the 2011 general elections, Singaporeans will probably not accept anyone whom they see as being a mere figurehead, a rubber stamp for the ruling party. To be a credible candidate for the post of Elected President, aspirants will have to demonstrate that they are above and beyond partisan politics and that their interests lie in the greater good of Singapore as a whole.
However, given the much emboldened polity, I am surprised that thus far only one person has openly come out to declare his intention to contest this august office. And even more surprising is the reaction his intention has drawn from his past colleagues.
Words like ‘awkward’, ‘mixed feelings’ from PAP members in response to Dr Tan Cheng Bock’s declared candidacy only serve to fuel speculation that the PAP-led government intends to nominate a candidate who is less likely to have an adversarial type of relationship with the government.
Obviously, Dr Tan had not made the PAP privy to his intention, and judging by the response from the party, it would also seem clear that Dr Tan was not of the government’s shortlist.
But just how serious a contender is Dr Tan? Well, given that Dr Tan has quit the PAP, Singaporeans should take his candidacy seriously. It is also worth noting that while he was a serving PAP Member of Parliament, Dr Tan had been one of the voices of reform from the backbenches. He was also known to have gone against the grain and voted against the party on issues.
For all intents and purposes, Dr Tan is currently the frontrunner for the upcoming Presidential elections, which must be held by 31 August. And he is the frontrunner despite the PAP’s attempts to “undermine” his candidacy.
And, the very same reasoning that has been used to question Dr Tan’s candidacy – that Singaporeans might prefer a President who is not so closely linked to the PAP – would actually also apply to other possible candidates that have been suggested by Presidential Election watchers, namely persons such as Mr Lee Kuan Yew, Mr George Yeo, Professor S Jayakumar, Dr Tony Tan, Mr Zainual Abidin Rasheed, and Mr Abdullah Tarmugi.
It is unlikely that Mr Lee or Mr Yeo will offer themselves to be President. Mr Yeo had already ruled himself out and it is unlikely that Mr Lee would want to take on a position that is primarily ceremonial in nature. And I do not think that Singaporeans would want to dabble with the possibility of the office of the President suddenly becoming a position with executive powers in the hands of Mr Lee.
It would come as a surprise though if Prof Jayakumar, Dr Tony Tan, Mr Zainul Abidin or Mr Abdullah suddenly steps forward to offer themselves as a candidate. For it would mean that they have quit the PAP. But a lingering question will remain: Where does their allegiance lie – to their former party or the people? This is because throughout their political careers, they have never broken rank with the party. So, will they be able to do so if elected President?
Of late, a few other wildcards have been thrown into the hat, with names like Mr Chiam See Tong, Madam Ho Ching (wife of Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong), Ms Catherine Lim and Ms Chan Heng Chee have been suggested as potential candidates by netizens.
If you ask me, Mr Chiam, Ms Lim and Ms Chan are most unlikely to step into the fray; Mr Chiam due to his declining health; Ms Lim based on her own admission that she can do more as a commentator than as an office holder; and Ms Chan . . . well, I could be proven wrong here.
As for Mdm Ho, again, very unlikely as it would not look good to have husband and wife as head of government and head of state, respectively. I don’t think that Singaporeans are ready to entirely cede the country to one family.
So, we are back where we began with our crystal ball gazing. Save for the declared intention of Dr Tan, we will just have to wait until tomorrow to know if there is going to be a race of the elected presidency.
I am hoping that there will be a race so that I can once again exercise my right to choose who I want to be the people’s guardian and the nation’s healer.

Friday, May 27, 2011

Singapore’s Elected President – Ceremonial Figurehead or the People’s Guardian?

Just as the dust begins to settle from the recent political contest for the hearts and minds of the people, a new electoral battle is looming on the horizon. By 31 August, Singaporeans will have gone to the polls again; this time to choose who they want as Singapore’s next Elected President.
This, of course, assumes that there will be contest as the past two Presidential Elections had passed uncontested and saw S R Nathan returned as the President in both 1999 and 2005. In both past elections, the other competing candidates had been disqualified for not meeting the raft of criteria needed to be declared eligible for the post.
The atmosphere somehow feels different this year.
Maybe it’s because the 2011 General Elections had brought about a political awakening of the Singapore polity, and whetted our appetite for exercising our power of choice at the ballot box.
Maybe it’s because Singaporeans want aspirants for the position of the Elected President to earn the support of voters so that they can serve with greater legitimacy.
Maybe after two uneventful terms of the Elected President, there are possible candidates out there who truly believe they can make a difference in the governance of Singapore.
Even as I write this, the Elections Department has issued a statement indicating that anyone wishing to be considered as a candidate can apply for a Certificate of Eligibility from 1 June 2011. The application must be submitted within three days from the issuance of the writ of Presidential Election.
A former People’s Action Party (PAP) Member of Parliament, Dr Tan Cheng Bock, has thrown his name into the hat as a possible candidate, and another name that has been coming up often is that of former NTUC Income chairman Tan Kin Lian.
While Dr Tan has offered himself as a candidate, he also hopes that more people will come forward to contest the position and lamented that he would be sad if there was no contest, because “it’s only through a contest that you feel that you are legitimately there because you have the support of the people.”
For now, these two men appear to be the front runners for the presidential elections, provided they obtain the Certificate of Eligibility. Despite their long past affiliation with the establishment, both men have displayed much independence of thought and are not afraid to challenge the powers that be to put right what is wrong.
Former Foreign Minister George Yeo had also been suggested as a possible candidate after his election defeat, but Mr Yeo has all but ruled himself out of the race. He had said that while he is flattered by the suggestion, “I’m a free spirit. I don’t think my temperament is suited for such a job.”
Who else can we expect to see named as possible candidates for the Presidential Elections?
Looking at the list of past presidents, it is notable that the last time a Malay-Muslim held the office was during the tenure of President Yusof Ishak, Singapore’s first president from 1965 to 1970.
Extending this train of thought, it is not beyond reason to consider both former Speaker of Parliament and Minister Abdullah Tarmugi and former Senior Minister of State Zainul Abidin Rasheed (who had been slated as the next Speaker had he been returned in GE2011) as possible candidates. However, their affiliation with the PAP may actually work against them.
Looking at the history of the Elected President, the only truly Elected President was the late Ong Teng Cheong, who served as President from 1993 to 1999. It was the only time Singaporeans had a say in their choice of President.
Although the office of the President is largely ceremonial, the 1991 constitutional amendment to create the office of the Elected President gave the President certain reserve powers over government expenditure of financial reserves and appointments to key public offices.
And it was these powers that were brought to bear in the dispute between President Ong and the government over access to information regarding Singapore’s financial reserves.
The dispute had come as a surprise given that President Ong had been a Cabinet minister in both the Lee Kuan Yew and Goh Chok Tong governments. On a more positive note, as a result of the dispute, President Ong came to be held in high regard by the people as a President for the people, a guardian of the people, coming close to the stature of his predecessor, the much beloved late President Wee Kim Wee (1985-1993). 
President Ong's successor, President Nathan, has had a more amicable relationship with the government, with no overt signs of the check-and-balancer and gatekeeper role that President Ong had tried to assert during his tenure. As of 2009, President Nathan also became Singapore’s longest serving President, surpassing the tenure of Singapore’s second President, Benjamin Sheares (1971-1981).
As we now prepare for ourselves for the next Presidential Elections, what will be our hopes and expectations of the next Elected President? Surely, after two uncontested Presidential Elections, the people must be eager to see willing and qualified individuals step forward to contest the post of the President.
After a general election that had threw up more than capable candidates for the opposition parties, hopes are high that we would want to see more than capable and qualified people contesting the elections. The last thing we want is for the Presidential Elections to devolve into a three-ring circus.
As befits the office, let us hope that all aspirants for the post of the Elected President will treat the position with the highest measure of respect and dignity, and place the greater interest of the country at the forefront of their quest.

Thursday, May 26, 2011

Ride of Silence – quietly championing the rights of cyclists


I participated in my first Ride of Silence this year after having heard about the event over the last couple of years. The event, which had its origins in the US in 2003, is in fact only in its third year in Singapore.
Held every year on the third Saturday of May, the Ride of Silence has grown across the world with more than 400 participating cities in 30 countries and sees cyclists coming together to remember those who have been injured or killed while cycling on the roads.
The event is also a way to promote cycling, safe cycling and sharing of public roads.
By way of statistics, it is estimated that everyday two cyclists are hit by a motor vehicle in Singapore, of which, every two weeks, one results in a fatality.
This year’s Ride of Silence, held on 21 May, saw a sizeable number of the local cycling community converging at the Marina Bay Sands Promenade for the 20 km ride through the Central Business District. Most had also come dressed in white tops in a show of solidarity for the message and meaning behind the Ride.
Cycling at a leisurely pace of not more than 20 kmh and escorted by safety marshals and outriders, the event drew the attention of people where ever we went. Hopefully, the sight of so many cyclists riding through town brought about a sense of awareness that cyclists are road users too and not just thoughts about the novelty of the sight.
At the end of the day, a fundamental question that needs asking is just how much of an impact an event like the Ride of Silence has on the mindshare of Singapore? Over the last three years, how much improvement has been made in terms of recognizing the rights of cyclists to the use of public roads? Also, how far have we progressed in terms of educating cyclists on safe cycling – not only for themselves but also for those with whom they share the roads and cycling paths?
Without a doubt, cycling – both as a leisure activity, sport and a mode of transport – has grown in popularity over the years in Singapore. It is a common sight these days to see cyclists on the roads at all hours of the day and all over the island, with the more experienced and seasoned riders taking to the roads confidently while the newbies tend to keep themselves to the pavements (which, by the way, is an offence in Singapore, except in Tampines town) and park connectors.
There will always be the good and the bad, and debates and discussions about cycling and cyclists are expected to continue unabated in the media and discussion forums. As an aside, just days after the Ride of Silence event, at least four letters to the media on the subject of cycling were published by the mainstream media.
And the debate about cycling and cyclist has been going on even before the Ride of Silence became a regular feature in our social calendar.
While the Ride of Silence is great as a ground up initiative (it is composed exclusively of volunteers), more could be done to raise its profile and by logical extension raise the awareness of the larger Singaporean society about cycling and the general plight of cyclists.
To just rely on the cycling community and the many cycling forums to spread the message is akin to preaching to the converted. A wider reach is required and this can only be achieved by harnessing the power of the mainstream media and/or sanctioned/sponsored mass cycling events to help spread the message.
Land scarce Singapore and her highly congested roads do not really make for a conducive environment for cycling, unless you cycle very early in the morning or very late at night but even then you would have to wary of drivers who suddenly think they are F1 drivers when the traffic volume is low.
Whenever a cyclist makes a decision to ride on the road, he/she is taking a risk and can only pray that drivers will not regard them as something that is not worthy of their notice. Think about it, as a cyclist, you are completely exposed to all the dangers associated with being on the road, and despite all your efforts to be safe, all it takes is one driver distracted or impatient driver to put you in harm’s way.
It was therefore such a welcome when a 1.5 metres safety distance campaign was launched in 2010 under the OCBC Cycle Singapore banner, with the slogan ‘1.5M Matters. Share the Road’.
The campaign can be seen as a way of finding the middle ground between cyclists and motorists as it reminded everyone that observing a safe distance of 1.5 metres from each other and obeying traffic rules will enable both parties to enjoy a safe journey on our roads. It also created awareness on the need for both cyclists and motorists to respect each other and share the road.
While some gains have been achieved in terms of getting cyclists a share of the road, much work has still to be done when it comes to cyclists sharing paths/trails with walkers/joggers/hikers. Currently, most paths along the network of park connectors are built as shared paths for cyclists and walkers/joggers.
This has led to some unhappiness among walkers/joggers when cyclists speed past them on such shared paths. It would be unfair to entirely fault the cyclist because he/she is after all trying to get a workout from the ride. To be fair to everyone, walkers/joggers should avoid spreading themselves across the whole path, especially if they are in a group. This would at least provide space for a cyclist to pass the group on the shared path safely.
Maybe we need specifically designated paths for cyclists and walkers/joggers. But then again, even when designated paths are built (like in the East Coast Park or along the Hillview Park Connector), it is not uncommon to find walkers/joggers straying onto the cycling paths, thereby causing obstruction to cyclists.
Sometimes, it’s just a no-win situation for a cyclist. But we must not lose hope, and the Ride of Silence offers us that glimmer of hope to further the cause of all cyclists. And I am hopeful that we will find a point of convergence that all parties can subscribe to in order to make the pursuit of our individual passions possible.